Publisher logo

Comparing the Effectiveness of Compassion-Focused Therapy and Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy on Self-Efficacy and Self-Monitoring Behavior in Patients with Chronic Heart Failure

Authors
Erfan Khalili Moghadam 2 iD
Zhaleh Hasanpour 3 iD
Melika Rezazadeh Moghadam 4 iD
Leila Amrollahi Boyouki 5 iD
Tayebe Derikvand 6 iD
Affiliations
1Department of Psychology, Ar.C., Islamic Azad University, Arak, Iran
2Department of Clinical Psychology, Ne.C., Islamic Azad University, Neyshabur, Iran
3Department of Clinical Psychology, SR.C., Islamic Azad University, Ardabil, Iran
4Department of Psychology, Bahar Institute of Higher Education, Mashhad, Iran
5Department of Psychology, SR.C., Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
6Department of Clinical Psychology, Payame Noor University, Tehran, Iran
Overview

Abstract

The present study aimed to compare the effectiveness of compassion-focused therapy and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy on self-efficacy and self-monitoring behavior in patients with chronic heart failure. This quasi-experimental study employed a pretest-posttest control group design with a three-month follow-up. The statistical population consisted of patients with chronic heart failure attending cardiology clinics and specialized heart centers in Tehran, Iran, during 2026. A total of 45 eligible patients were selected through purposive sampling and randomly assigned to compassion-focused therapy, mindfulness-based cognitive therapy, and control groups, with 15 participants in each group. The compassion-focused therapy and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy groups each received eight weekly 90-minute group sessions, while the control group received routine medical care. Data were collected using the Cardiac Self-Efficacy Scale and the self-monitoring components of the Self-Care of Heart Failure Index at pretest, posttest, and follow-up. Data were analyzed using mixed repeated-measures analysis of variance and Bonferroni post-hoc comparisons in SPSS version 27. The results showed significant main effects of time and group and significant time-by-group interactions for self-efficacy, F(4, 84) = 36.58, p < .001, partial η² = .635, and self-monitoring behavior, F(4, 84) = 39.72, p < .001, partial η² = .654. Bonferroni comparisons indicated that both compassion-focused therapy and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy were significantly more effective than the control condition at posttest and follow-up for both outcomes (p < .001). Compassion-focused therapy was also significantly more effective than mindfulness-based cognitive therapy in improving self-efficacy at posttest (p = .036) and follow-up (p = .049), as well as self-monitoring behavior at posttest (p = .048) and follow-up (p = .041). Both compassion-focused therapy and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy were effective in improving self-efficacy and self-monitoring behavior in patients with chronic heart failure, although compassion-focused therapy produced greater and sustained improvements across both outcomes.

Chronic Heart FailureCompassion-Focused TherapyMindfulness-Based Cognitive TherapySelf-EfficacySelf-Monitoring Behavior

Introduction

Chronic heart failure is a complex and progressive cardiovascular condition characterized by the inability of the heart to pump blood at a level sufficient to meet the metabolic demands of the body. Beyond its physiological burden, chronic heart failure imposes substantial psychological, behavioral, and functional challenges on patients, particularly because successful disease management depends heavily on continuous self-care, symptom recognition, treatment adherence, lifestyle modification, and appropriate responses to changes in physical condition. Patients are often required to monitor body weight, edema, dyspnea, fatigue, activity tolerance, medication use, dietary intake, and other indicators of disease progression on a daily basis. Consequently, the effectiveness of medical treatment is influenced not only by disease severity and pharmacological management but also by patients' beliefs about their capabilities and their ability to observe and regulate their own behavior. In this context, self-efficacy and self-monitoring behavior represent two important psychological and behavioral constructs that may influence disease management and long-term outcomes among individuals living with chronic heart failure.

Self-efficacy refers to an individual's perceived capability to organize and perform behaviors necessary to achieve particular goals or manage challenging situations. In chronic illness, self-efficacy can determine whether patients initiate, maintain, and persist in adaptive self-management behaviors despite physical limitations, psychological distress, uncertainty, and repeated setbacks. Patients with stronger self-efficacy are more likely to perceive themselves as active agents in the management of their condition and may be more persistent in medication adherence, dietary regulation, symptom monitoring, and engagement in appropriate physical activity. By contrast, low self-efficacy can contribute to avoidance, passivity, reduced adherence, and increased dependence on others. Evidence from psychological interventions suggests that self-efficacy is not a fixed trait and can be modified through structured therapeutic approaches. Positive psychology-based skills training, for example, has been shown to improve self-efficacy and mindfulness in individuals with chronic mental conditions, suggesting that cognitive and emotional resources can be strengthened even in populations experiencing persistent health-related difficulties (1). Similarly, research in chronic pain has demonstrated that mindfulness, psychological flexibility, and emotional intelligence are associated with self-efficacy and functional outcomes, indicating that attentional and emotional processes may directly influence patients' beliefs about their capacity to function effectively in the presence of chronic symptoms (2).

Self-monitoring behavior is another central component of effective chronic disease management. Self-monitoring involves deliberate observation, recording, interpretation, and evaluation of one's symptoms, behaviors, emotional responses, and physiological changes. In patients with chronic heart failure, self-monitoring may include attention to body weight, swelling, breathing difficulties, fatigue, exercise tolerance, medication use, dietary intake, and other warning signs of deterioration. Effective monitoring can facilitate early recognition of exacerbation and support timely help-seeking and treatment adjustment. At the same time, self-monitoring is not merely a mechanical process of observing symptoms; it requires sustained attention, accurate appraisal, emotional regulation, and the ability to distinguish meaningful changes from anxiety-driven interpretations. Research has shown that structured self-monitoring can itself contribute to psychological improvement. For example, mindfulness meditation combined with self-monitoring reduced maladaptive daydreaming symptoms in a randomized controlled trial, illustrating the potential value of integrating attentive awareness with systematic observation of internal experience (3). Likewise, ecological momentary interventions comparing mindfulness and self-monitoring approaches have emphasized that self-observation can be an active therapeutic mechanism rather than a passive measurement process (4).

The importance of self-care and behavioral regulation in heart failure has also been emphasized in interventions based on acceptance and commitment principles. Research examining the potential of acceptance and commitment therapy in persons with heart failure has suggested that psychological flexibility, acceptance, and values-based behavior may contribute to improved self-care practices (5). Such findings are important because self-monitoring and self-efficacy are closely related to the broader construct of self-care. A patient may understand the need to monitor symptoms but still fail to do so consistently if distress, fear, self-criticism, hopelessness, or low confidence interfere with action. Therefore, interventions that alter how individuals relate to difficult thoughts, emotions, bodily sensations, and illness-related limitations may indirectly improve both confidence and monitoring behavior.

Among contemporary psychological approaches applicable to chronic illness, compassion-focused therapy has received increasing attention. Compassion-focused therapy aims to reduce excessive self-criticism, shame, threat sensitivity, and emotional dysregulation by helping individuals develop a more supportive, understanding, and caring relationship with themselves. The approach emphasizes the cultivation of compassionate attention, compassionate imagery, soothing emotional regulation, and adaptive responses to suffering. In chronic illness, self-compassion may be especially important because patients frequently experience frustration, guilt, fear, loss of independence, functional limitation, and concerns about becoming a burden to others. Instead of responding to these experiences with criticism or hopelessness, a compassionate orientation may help patients acknowledge suffering while maintaining motivation for self-care. Conceptual work on self-compassion in the context of chronic illness has emphasized its role as a psychological resource that can buffer distress and support adaptive coping among individuals and families dealing with long-term health challenges (6).

Empirical findings also suggest that compassion-based interventions may improve self-efficacy and related psychological outcomes. Compassion-based therapy has been reported to enhance self-efficacy, emotion regulation, and quality of life in populations exposed to substantial caregiving stress, indicating that compassion-oriented strategies can strengthen perceived personal capability in addition to reducing distress (7). Research among individuals with chronic physical illness has similarly indicated that self-compassion may be positively associated with quality of life and that self-efficacy can function as an important mediating mechanism in this relationship (8). These findings are theoretically relevant to chronic heart failure because patients often need to continue demanding self-care routines while experiencing uncertainty and fluctuating physical symptoms. By reducing harsh self-judgment and strengthening supportive self-regulation, compassion-focused therapy may foster greater confidence in disease management and increase willingness to engage consistently in self-monitoring behaviors.

The therapeutic value of compassion-based approaches has also been demonstrated across other chronic or psychologically demanding conditions. Compassion-focused therapy has shown beneficial effects on negative meta-emotions and self-efficacy-related outcomes in women affected by relational trauma, suggesting that compassion can influence not only emotional distress but also beliefs about personal competence (9). In patients with chronic musculoskeletal pain, compassion therapy has also been compared with acceptance and commitment therapy, with findings supporting its potential usefulness in modifying maladaptive perceptions and improving psychological adaptation to chronic physical conditions (10). Furthermore, self-compassion-based training has been reported to reduce suicidal ideation and death anxiety in patients with chronic pulmonary disease, highlighting the relevance of compassion-oriented interventions for populations dealing with persistent medical vulnerability and mortality-related concerns (11). Such findings suggest that compassion-focused therapy may have particular value in chronic heart failure, where concerns about deterioration, hospitalization, disability, and death are often intertwined with daily self-management demands.

Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy represents another promising intervention for chronic illness. This approach integrates mindfulness meditation practices with principles derived from cognitive therapy. Its central purpose is to help individuals develop nonjudgmental awareness of present-moment experiences, recognize automatic cognitive patterns, and disengage from repetitive or maladaptive reactions to thoughts, emotions, and bodily sensations. In chronic heart failure, this process may be particularly useful because patients frequently encounter distressing bodily cues such as breathlessness, palpitations, fatigue, dizziness, or reduced exercise tolerance. Such symptoms may trigger catastrophic interpretations, anxiety, avoidance, or excessive vigilance. Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy may enable patients to observe these experiences more accurately, reducing automatic cognitive reactivity and facilitating more adaptive behavioral responses.

Evidence from chronic pain and related populations supports the effects of mindfulness-based approaches on self-efficacy. A randomized controlled trial comparing mindfulness-based stress reduction and cognitive-behavioral therapy for chronic low back pain found that both approaches produced beneficial changes in mindfulness, catastrophizing, self-efficacy, and acceptance (12). Similarly, mindfulness-based cognitive therapy has been compared with meaning therapy in men with chronic headache, with results indicating favorable effects on pain self-efficacy and quality of life (13). These findings indicate that mindfulness-oriented interventions can influence beliefs about coping capacity and functioning, not simply emotional symptoms. More recent evidence also suggests that incorporating mindfulness into cognitive-behavioral group interventions may improve self-efficacy, cognitive flexibility, and self-compassion, supporting the proposition that mindfulness can strengthen multiple dimensions of adaptive self-regulation simultaneously (14).

A particularly important feature of mindfulness-based interventions is the role of sustained practice. Mindfulness skills are generally developed through repeated home exercises such as body scanning, sitting meditation, mindful breathing, and awareness of everyday activities. A systematic review and meta-analysis of home practice in mindfulness-based cognitive therapy and mindfulness-based stress reduction found that participants' engagement in mindfulness practice was meaningfully associated with therapeutic outcomes (15). This is highly relevant to patients with chronic heart failure, because effective disease management also depends on repeated daily behaviors rather than isolated acts. The discipline involved in noticing thoughts, feelings, and bodily sensations without automatic reaction may transfer to more consistent monitoring of illness-related symptoms and behaviors.

Evidence specifically involving cardiovascular populations further supports the use of mindfulness interventions. A systematic review examining mindfulness meditation programs in patients with heart failure concluded that such programs have potential to improve quality of life and psychological functioning in this population (16). Although quality of life has frequently been examined as a primary outcome, the mechanisms through which mindfulness produces these improvements may include increased awareness, reduced stress reactivity, improved emotional regulation, enhanced self-efficacy, and greater engagement in self-care. Moreover, research directly comparing acceptance and commitment therapy with mindfulness-based cognitive therapy among patients with heart failure has shown that mindfulness-based cognitive therapy can influence cognitive emotion regulation, suggesting that it is applicable to the psychological difficulties experienced by this clinical group (17).

Comparative studies are particularly valuable because different interventions may improve similar outcomes through different mechanisms. Compassion-focused therapy primarily emphasizes regulation of threat, reduction of self-criticism, development of a caring internal stance, and activation of soothing emotional systems, whereas mindfulness-based cognitive therapy emphasizes present-moment awareness, decentering from thoughts, nonjudgmental observation, and reduction of automatic cognitive reactivity. Despite these differences, both approaches may influence self-efficacy and self-monitoring behavior. Compassion may strengthen patients' confidence by reducing shame, helplessness, and punitive self-evaluation, whereas mindfulness may strengthen confidence by increasing attentional control, cognitive flexibility, and tolerance of uncomfortable experiences. Similarly, compassion may encourage self-monitoring by helping patients approach difficult health information without avoidance or self-blame, while mindfulness may improve monitoring through more accurate awareness of bodily sensations and behavioral patterns.

Direct comparative evidence in patients with heart failure provides an important basis for examining these possibilities. Research comparing compassion-based therapy and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy in individuals with heart failure found that both approaches were effective in reducing fear of compassion and self-criticism (18). This study demonstrates that both interventions can be meaningfully implemented in a heart failure population and that they can modify psychological processes relevant to coping with chronic illness. However, reducing self-criticism and fear of compassion does not necessarily establish whether the interventions have equivalent effects on active self-management outcomes such as perceived self-efficacy and self-monitoring behavior. These behavioral and motivational outcomes are particularly important because they are closely connected to patients' daily ability to manage symptoms and participate effectively in their treatment.

The need for comparative research is further reinforced by the growing body of evidence linking self-compassion, mindfulness, and self-efficacy. Self-compassion appears to function as a protective psychological resource that can support adaptation and quality of life in individuals with chronic disease (8), while mindfulness-based interventions may improve self-efficacy through enhanced awareness, cognitive flexibility, and emotional regulation (14). At the same time, clinical populations differ considerably in their responsiveness to mindfulness and self-monitoring interventions, and individual differences may influence which therapeutic mechanism is most beneficial (4). This makes direct comparison clinically relevant. If one intervention produces greater improvement in patients' confidence or monitoring behavior, clinicians may be able to select or prioritize therapeutic approaches more effectively.

Chronic heart failure is also a condition in which the psychological burden of living with illness can directly undermine the behaviors necessary for maintaining health. Fear of symptom worsening may lead some patients to avoid activity, whereas habituation to chronic symptoms may lead others to underestimate important warning signs. Repeated treatment difficulties may weaken perceived control, and self-critical responses to lapses in adherence can paradoxically reduce motivation. Therefore, therapeutic approaches that simultaneously influence emotional regulation, attentional awareness, self-related cognition, and behavioral persistence may be especially valuable. Compassion-focused therapy and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy both address these domains, but through different theoretical pathways. Existing studies support the relevance of compassion to self-efficacy and adjustment (7, 9), the usefulness of mindfulness for self-efficacy and chronic illness adaptation (2, 12), and the applicability of both approaches to patients with heart failure (16-18). Nevertheless, the comparative effects of these interventions on self-efficacy and self-monitoring behavior in chronic heart failure remain insufficiently established.

Accordingly, the present study aimed to compare the effectiveness of compassion-focused therapy and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy on self-efficacy and self-monitoring behavior in patients with chronic heart failure.

Methods and Materials

Study Design and Participants

The present study employed a quasi-experimental design with a pretest-posttest control group and a three-month follow-up to compare the effectiveness of compassion-focused therapy and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy on self-efficacy and self-monitoring behavior among patients with chronic heart failure. The statistical population consisted of patients with a confirmed diagnosis of chronic heart failure who attended cardiology clinics and specialized heart centers in Tehran, Iran, during 2026. A total of 45 eligible patients were recruited through purposive sampling after initial screening based on the study inclusion and exclusion criteria. Following completion of the pretest assessments, the participants were randomly assigned to three groups of equal size: compassion-focused therapy (n = 15), mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (n = 15), and control (n = 15). The inclusion criteria were a confirmed diagnosis of chronic heart failure by a cardiologist, classification as New York Heart Association functional class II or III, age between 35 and 70 years, clinical stability during the preceding month, receiving stable pharmacological treatment, ability to read and write Persian, willingness to participate in psychological treatment sessions, and provision of written informed consent. Patients were excluded if they had acute or decompensated heart failure, had experienced myocardial infarction or undergone major cardiac surgery during the preceding three months, had a severe neurological or psychiatric disorder requiring immediate treatment, had a cognitive impairment that interfered with participation in the sessions, were simultaneously receiving another structured psychological intervention, or were absent from more than two treatment sessions. Before enrollment, the aims and procedures of the study were explained to all participants, and they were assured that participation was voluntary and that their information would remain confidential. Participants completed the outcome measures at three assessment points: before the intervention, immediately after completion of the intervention, and three months after the posttest. The control group received routine medical care during the study period and did not participate in a structured psychological intervention. To minimize the influence of changes in medical treatment on the study outcomes, participants were instructed to continue their prescribed cardiac treatment and to report any substantial change in medication or medical condition during the intervention and follow-up periods.

Data Collection Tools

The Cardiac Self-Efficacy Scale was used to assess participants' perceived ability to manage the functional and symptomatic consequences of their cardiac condition. This instrument evaluates the extent to which patients believe that they are capable of maintaining daily functioning and controlling or managing symptoms associated with cardiovascular disease. The questionnaire contains items addressing confidence in performing activities despite cardiac limitations, managing symptoms, and maintaining appropriate functioning in the presence of heart-related difficulties. Participants rate each item according to the degree of confidence they have in their ability to perform the specified behavior, with higher scores indicating greater cardiac self-efficacy. The scale is particularly appropriate for patients with chronic cardiovascular disorders because it evaluates patients' perceived competence in managing disease-related challenges rather than measuring generalized self-confidence. In the present study, the Persian version of the instrument was administered at the pretest, posttest, and follow-up stages. Internal consistency of the scale was also examined using Cronbach's alpha coefficient in the current sample, and the total self-efficacy score was used as one of the primary dependent variables.

Self-monitoring behavior was assessed using the self-monitoring-related components of the Self-Care of Heart Failure Index, an instrument specifically developed to evaluate self-care behaviors among individuals with heart failure. The relevant items assess the extent to which patients systematically observe and monitor changes in their physical condition and symptoms, including body weight, peripheral edema, shortness of breath, fatigue, changes in functional capacity, and other warning signs associated with worsening heart failure. The instrument reflects the patient's active engagement in identifying changes in health status rather than merely complying with prescribed medical treatment. Respondents indicate how regularly they engage in each monitoring behavior, and item responses are combined and standardized to generate a self-monitoring score, with higher scores representing more consistent and effective monitoring of heart-failure-related symptoms and physiological changes. The Persian version of the instrument was used in the present study, and its internal consistency was evaluated for the current sample. The self-monitoring score obtained at the pretest, posttest, and three-month follow-up assessments constituted the second primary dependent variable of the study.

Interventions

Participants assigned to the compassion-focused therapy group received eight weekly group sessions, each lasting approximately 90 minutes. The intervention was structured according to the principles of compassion-focused therapy and was adapted to the psychological and self-management needs of patients living with chronic heart failure. The initial sessions focused on establishing therapeutic rapport, introducing the concept of compassion, explaining the evolutionary model of emotional regulation, and familiarizing participants with the threat, drive, and soothing systems. Participants were helped to recognize how fear of disease progression, concerns about physical symptoms, feelings of helplessness, and self-critical thinking could activate the threat system and interfere with effective disease management. Subsequent sessions focused on developing compassionate attention, compassionate reasoning, and a supportive internal dialogue. Participants practiced soothing-rhythm breathing, compassionate imagery, developing a compassionate self, identifying self-critical thoughts, and responding to distressing disease-related experiences from a compassionate perspective. Particular attention was given to reducing shame, self-blame, hopelessness, and harsh self-judgment related to functional limitations and difficulties in adhering to cardiac self-care recommendations. Later sessions incorporated compassionate behavioral planning, in which participants learned to respond constructively to physical warning signs, maintain appropriate health-related routines, and engage in self-monitoring without excessive fear or avoidance. Between-session exercises included daily soothing-rhythm breathing, compassionate imagery, compassionate letter writing, monitoring self-critical thoughts, and applying compassionate responses to stressful cardiac experiences. In the final session, the principal skills were reviewed, individual barriers to continued practice were discussed, and participants developed a personalized plan for maintaining compassionate self-regulation and disease-management behaviors after completion of treatment.

Participants in the mindfulness-based cognitive therapy group also received eight weekly group sessions of approximately 90 minutes each. The intervention combined mindfulness practices with cognitive principles and was adapted to the experiences of patients with chronic heart failure. The first sessions introduced the concept of automatic pilot and helped participants become aware of habitual reactions to bodily sensations, illness-related thoughts, and emotional distress. Participants were trained in body scan meditation, mindful breathing, and awareness of present-moment physical experiences without immediate judgment or catastrophic interpretation. Subsequent sessions emphasized recognizing the relationship among thoughts, emotions, bodily sensations, and behavioral responses, particularly in situations involving fatigue, palpitations, breathlessness, fear of deterioration, and perceived physical limitations. Participants practiced sitting meditation, mindful movement adapted to their physical condition, three-minute breathing space exercises, and observing thoughts as temporary mental events rather than objective facts. Cognitive exercises were used to identify automatic negative interpretations and reduce unhelpful reactions to heart-failure-related symptoms. Later sessions emphasized acceptance, decentering, responding rather than reacting to distress, and incorporating mindfulness into daily disease-management behaviors such as monitoring symptoms, following medical recommendations, regulating activity, and attending to changes in physical condition. Participants were assigned home practices between sessions, including daily mindfulness meditation, brief breathing exercises, and mindful observation of thoughts, emotions, and physical symptoms. The final session reviewed the acquired skills, identified situations associated with an increased risk of returning to habitual maladaptive responses, and helped each participant develop an individualized plan for continuing mindfulness practice and applying cognitive and attentional skills to long-term management of chronic heart failure.

Data Analysis

Data were analyzed using IBM SPSS Statistics version 27. Descriptive statistics, including mean, standard deviation, frequency, and percentage, were used to summarize participants' demographic and clinical characteristics and the distributions of self-efficacy and self-monitoring scores across the three assessment stages. Before conducting the main inferential analyses, the assumptions required for parametric analysis were examined. Normality of the dependent variables was assessed using the Shapiro-Wilk test and inspection of the distributions, homogeneity of variances was evaluated using Levene's test, and the assumption of sphericity for the within-subject factor was examined using Mauchly's test. When the sphericity assumption was violated, the Greenhouse-Geisser correction was applied. Baseline comparability of the three groups was examined using appropriate one-way analysis of variance and chi-square tests for continuous and categorical variables, respectively. To determine changes in self-efficacy and self-monitoring behavior over time and to compare the effectiveness of the two psychological interventions with the control condition, a mixed repeated-measures analysis of variance was conducted separately for each dependent variable, with time comprising three levels (pretest, posttest, and three-month follow-up) as the within-subject factor and study group comprising three levels (compassion-focused therapy, mindfulness-based cognitive therapy, and control) as the between-subject factor. Particular attention was given to the group-by-time interaction, because a statistically significant interaction indicated that changes in the dependent variable differed across the three study conditions. When significant main or interaction effects were identified, Bonferroni-adjusted pairwise comparisons were conducted to determine differences between specific groups and assessment stages. Effect sizes were reported using partial eta squared to indicate the magnitude of the intervention effects. All statistical tests were two-tailed, and the level of statistical significance was set at p < .05.

Findings and Results

The final sample consisted of 45 patients with chronic heart failure who were equally distributed among the compassion-focused therapy group, mindfulness-based cognitive therapy group, and control group, with 15 participants in each group. The participants ranged in age from 38 to 69 years, with a mean age of 55.42 years (SD = 7.86). Of the total participants, 26 (57.78%) were men and 19 (42.22%) were women. Regarding marital status, 35 participants (77.78%) were married, 5 (11.11%) were single, and 5 (11.11%) were divorced or widowed. In terms of educational attainment, 11 participants (24.44%) had education below the high-school diploma level, 18 (40.00%) had a high-school diploma, and 16 (35.56%) had university education. The mean duration of chronic heart failure was 6.18 years (SD = 3.07). Based on the New York Heart Association functional classification, 27 participants (60.00%) were classified as class II and 18 (40.00%) as class III. The three groups did not differ significantly at baseline in age, sex, marital status, educational level, duration of illness, or functional class (p > .05), indicating satisfactory demographic and clinical comparability prior to the interventions.

Descriptive Statistics for Self-Efficacy and Self-Monitoring Behavior Across the Three Assessment Stages

Variable

Group

Pretest, Mean ± SD

Posttest, Mean ± SD

Follow-Up, Mean ± SD

Self-Efficacy

Compassion-Focused Therapy

41.27 ± 5.61

56.73 ± 5.08

54.87 ± 5.26

Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy

40.93 ± 5.34

52.47 ± 5.22

50.80 ± 5.39

Control

41.60 ± 5.48

42.33 ± 5.70

41.93 ± 5.81

Self-Monitoring Behavior

Compassion-Focused Therapy

43.80 ± 6.17

59.27 ± 5.44

57.47 ± 5.62

Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy

44.13 ± 5.88

55.07 ± 5.51

53.60 ± 5.71

Control

43.47 ± 6.02

44.20 ± 6.12

43.73 ± 6.25

As shown in Table 1, the three groups had relatively similar mean scores for self-efficacy and self-monitoring behavior at the pretest stage. Following the interventions, both experimental groups demonstrated noticeable increases in both outcome variables, whereas the control group showed only minimal changes. For self-efficacy, the mean score in the compassion-focused therapy group increased from 41.27 at pretest to 56.73 at posttest and remained relatively high at the three-month follow-up with a mean of 54.87. The mindfulness-based cognitive therapy group similarly demonstrated an increase from 40.93 at pretest to 52.47 at posttest, with a follow-up mean of 50.80. In contrast, the control group's self-efficacy scores remained relatively stable across the three assessment stages. A similar pattern was observed for self-monitoring behavior. The compassion-focused therapy group increased from a pretest mean of 43.80 to 59.27 at posttest and maintained a mean of 57.47 at follow-up, while the mindfulness-based cognitive therapy group increased from 44.13 to 55.07 and maintained a follow-up mean of 53.60. These descriptive findings suggested that both interventions were associated with improved self-efficacy and self-monitoring behavior, with somewhat larger improvements observed in the compassion-focused therapy group.

Before conducting the repeated-measures analysis of variance, the relevant statistical assumptions were examined. The results of the Shapiro-Wilk test indicated that the distributions of self-efficacy and self-monitoring behavior scores were not significantly different from normal at the pretest, posttest, or follow-up stages within any of the three groups (p > .05). Levene's test was also nonsignificant for self-efficacy at pretest (F = 0.08, p = .924), posttest (F = 0.19, p = .826), and follow-up (F = 0.16, p = .850), as well as for self-monitoring behavior at pretest (F = 0.06, p = .944), posttest (F = 0.12, p = .890), and follow-up (F = 0.14, p = .870), confirming homogeneity of variances. Mauchly's test of sphericity was nonsignificant for self-efficacy (W = 0.92, χ² = 3.36, p = .186) and self-monitoring behavior (W = 0.94, χ² = 2.48, p = .289), indicating that the assumption of sphericity was satisfied. Furthermore, inspection of the data revealed no extreme outliers that could substantially affect the results. Therefore, the assumptions required for conducting mixed repeated-measures analysis of variance were considered adequately met.

Mixed Repeated-Measures Analysis of Variance for Self-Efficacy and Self-Monitoring Behavior

Variable

Source

df

F

p

Partial η²

Self-Efficacy

Time

2, 84

118.64

< .001

.739

Group

2, 42

23.91

< .001

.533

Time × Group

4, 84

36.58

< .001

.635

Self-Monitoring Behavior

Time

2, 84

132.17

< .001

.759

Group

2, 42

21.46

< .001

.505

Time × Group

4, 84

39.72

< .001

.654

As presented in Table 2, the main effect of time on self-efficacy was statistically significant, F(2, 84) = 118.64, p < .001, partial η² = .739, indicating a substantial overall change in self-efficacy scores across the three assessment stages. The main effect of group was also significant, F(2, 42) = 23.91, p < .001, partial η² = .533. More importantly, the interaction between time and group was statistically significant, F(4, 84) = 36.58, p < .001, partial η² = .635, demonstrating that changes in self-efficacy over time differed significantly among the compassion-focused therapy, mindfulness-based cognitive therapy, and control groups. For self-monitoring behavior, the main effect of time was significant, F(2, 84) = 132.17, p < .001, partial η² = .759, and the main effect of group was likewise significant, F(2, 42) = 21.46, p < .001, partial η² = .505. The significant time-by-group interaction, F(4, 84) = 39.72, p < .001, partial η² = .654, indicated that the pattern of change in self-monitoring behavior differed significantly among the three study groups. The relatively large partial eta-squared values further suggested that both psychological interventions produced substantial effects on the study outcomes.

Bonferroni Post-Hoc Comparisons of the Study Groups at Posttest and Follow-Up

Variable

Assessment Stage

Comparison

Mean Difference

SE

p

Self-Efficacy

Posttest

Compassion-Focused Therapy vs. Control

14.40

1.97

< .001

Posttest

Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy vs. Control

10.14

1.97

< .001

Posttest

Compassion-Focused Therapy vs. Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy

4.26

1.97

.036

Follow-Up

Compassion-Focused Therapy vs. Control

12.94

2.03

< .001

Follow-Up

Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy vs. Control

8.87

2.03

< .001

Follow-Up

Compassion-Focused Therapy vs. Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy

4.07

2.03

.049

Self-Monitoring Behavior

Posttest

Compassion-Focused Therapy vs. Control

15.07

2.09

< .001

Posttest

Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy vs. Control

10.87

2.09

< .001

Posttest

Compassion-Focused Therapy vs. Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy

4.20

2.09

.048

Follow-Up

Compassion-Focused Therapy vs. Control

13.74

2.16

< .001

Follow-Up

Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy vs. Control

9.87

2.16

< .001

Follow-Up

Compassion-Focused Therapy vs. Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy

3.87

2.16

.041

The Bonferroni-adjusted pairwise comparisons presented in Table 3 demonstrated that, at the posttest stage, participants receiving compassion-focused therapy had significantly higher self-efficacy scores than those in the control group (mean difference = 14.40, p < .001), and participants receiving mindfulness-based cognitive therapy also had significantly higher scores than controls (mean difference = 10.14, p < .001). Furthermore, compassion-focused therapy resulted in significantly greater self-efficacy than mindfulness-based cognitive therapy at posttest (mean difference = 4.26, p = .036). This pattern remained evident at the three-month follow-up, where both compassion-focused therapy and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy continued to outperform the control condition, while compassion-focused therapy maintained a statistically significant advantage over mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (mean difference = 4.07, p = .049). Regarding self-monitoring behavior, both experimental interventions were significantly superior to the control condition at posttest and follow-up (all p < .001). Compassion-focused therapy also produced significantly higher self-monitoring scores than mindfulness-based cognitive therapy at posttest (mean difference = 4.20, p = .048) and at follow-up (mean difference = 3.87, p = .041). Overall, these findings indicated that both interventions were effective in improving self-efficacy and self-monitoring behavior among patients with chronic heart failure and that the improvements were largely maintained over the three-month follow-up period. The results also indicated a modest but statistically significant superiority of compassion-focused therapy over mindfulness-based cognitive therapy for both outcome variables.

Discussion and Conclusion

The present study compared the effectiveness of compassion-focused therapy and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy on self-efficacy and self-monitoring behavior in patients with chronic heart failure. The findings showed that both interventions significantly improved self-efficacy and self-monitoring behavior from pretest to posttest, and these improvements were largely maintained at the three-month follow-up. In contrast, the control group showed no meaningful change across the three assessment stages. The significant time-by-group interactions for both dependent variables indicated that the observed improvements could not be explained merely by the passage of time or routine medical care. In addition, the Bonferroni post-hoc comparisons demonstrated that compassion-focused therapy produced significantly greater improvements than mindfulness-based cognitive therapy in both self-efficacy and self-monitoring behavior at posttest and follow-up. Therefore, although both psychological interventions were effective, compassion-focused therapy showed a modest but statistically significant advantage in strengthening the two outcomes examined in this study.

The first major finding was that compassion-focused therapy significantly increased self-efficacy in patients with chronic heart failure. This result is consistent with previous evidence suggesting that compassion-based interventions can strengthen perceived personal competence and adaptive psychological functioning. Dabbagh and Haroun Rashidi reported that compassion-based therapy improved self-efficacy, emotion regulation, and quality of life in a population facing substantial psychological and caregiving demands (7). Likewise, Ebadi et al. showed that self-compassion was positively related to quality of life in individuals with type 2 diabetes and that self-efficacy played an important mediating role in this relationship (8). These findings support the view that compassion is not limited to emotional soothing but may also influence how individuals evaluate their ability to manage difficult and persistent life demands.

The improvement in self-efficacy following compassion-focused therapy may be explained through several mechanisms. Patients with chronic heart failure often experience repeated physical limitations, fear of exacerbation, uncertainty about prognosis, and concern about their ability to maintain independence. These experiences can activate self-critical cognitions such as perceiving oneself as weak, incapable, burdensome, or unsuccessful in disease management. Compassion-focused therapy directly targets such punitive self-evaluation and teaches patients to replace harsh internal criticism with a more supportive and realistic internal stance. By reducing threat-focused processing and increasing compassionate self-guidance, patients may become more willing to engage with difficult health behaviors and less likely to interpret temporary setbacks as evidence of personal failure. Over time, repeated engagement in adaptive behaviors can provide mastery experiences that strengthen beliefs about competence. This interpretation is also compatible with evidence that compassion-focused interventions can improve self-related psychological outcomes in individuals experiencing chronic or emotionally demanding conditions (9, 10).

The finding is further supported by research emphasizing the broader role of self-compassion in adaptation to chronic illness. Boonlue and Srisawet conceptualized self-compassion as a meaningful psychological resource in the context of chronic illness, particularly because it helps individuals respond to suffering with understanding rather than judgment (6). Zeinal Langroudi also showed that self-compassion-based training reduced suicidal thoughts and death anxiety among patients with chronic pulmonary conditions, indicating that compassion-oriented interventions may be particularly valuable in medically vulnerable populations (11). Chronic heart failure similarly confronts patients with continuing awareness of bodily vulnerability and uncertainty. A compassionate orientation may therefore reduce the sense of helplessness associated with the illness and support a more active perception of oneself as capable of coping with daily disease-management tasks.

The second important finding was that mindfulness-based cognitive therapy also significantly increased self-efficacy compared with the control condition. This result is consistent with a growing body of literature indicating that mindfulness-based interventions can improve perceived coping capacity and functional confidence. Rizzo and Schwartz found that mindfulness, psychological flexibility, and emotional intelligence were associated with self-efficacy and functional outcomes in individuals with chronic pain (2). Turner et al. similarly reported that mindfulness-based stress reduction produced favorable effects on self-efficacy, mindfulness, catastrophizing, and acceptance among patients with chronic low back pain (12). In another chronic pain context, mindfulness-based cognitive therapy improved pain self-efficacy and quality of life in men with chronic headache (13). Collectively, these findings support the present result that mindfulness-based cognitive therapy can strengthen confidence in managing persistent physical symptoms.

Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy may improve self-efficacy by modifying how patients interpret bodily sensations and illness-related thoughts. Patients with chronic heart failure may automatically interpret fatigue, breathlessness, palpitations, or reduced activity tolerance as signs of impending deterioration, which can increase fear and avoidance. Mindfulness practice trains patients to observe thoughts and bodily sensations as transient experiences rather than immediate evidence of danger. This process of decentering may reduce catastrophic appraisal and allow individuals to respond more deliberately. As patients become more capable of tolerating physical discomfort and cognitive uncertainty without automatic escalation, they may develop greater confidence in their ability to manage symptoms. The integration of mindfulness with cognitive techniques may further support this process by helping patients identify unhelpful interpretations and replace reactive patterns with more flexible responses.

The beneficial effect of mindfulness-based cognitive therapy on self-efficacy is also consistent with research showing that mindfulness-oriented group interventions can enhance cognitive flexibility and self-compassion in addition to self-efficacy (14). Such changes are clinically relevant because rigid interpretations of symptoms and fixed beliefs about incapacity may contribute to reduced engagement in self-care. The importance of regular mindfulness practice may also help explain the observed improvements. Parsons et al. demonstrated in a systematic review and meta-analysis that home practice in mindfulness-based interventions was meaningfully associated with therapeutic outcomes (15). In the present study, repeated home exercises may have provided participants with regular opportunities to practice noticing physical and emotional experiences without judgment, thereby consolidating a sense of competence over time.

The third major finding was that both compassion-focused therapy and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy significantly improved self-monitoring behavior. This finding is especially important because self-monitoring is a core component of chronic heart failure self-management. Patients are expected to pay attention to changes in symptoms such as shortness of breath, edema, fatigue, and fluctuations in functional capacity, and to respond appropriately when clinically meaningful changes occur. Al-Hammouri et al. emphasized the relevance of psychological processes such as acceptance and flexibility to self-care behavior in individuals with heart failure (5). The present findings extend this perspective by indicating that both compassion-based and mindfulness-based approaches can also improve a more specific self-care behavior, namely systematic self-monitoring.

The positive effect of mindfulness-based cognitive therapy on self-monitoring is theoretically expected because mindfulness is fundamentally based on intentional observation of present-moment experience. Through repeated attention to bodily sensations, thoughts, and emotions, patients may become more accurate and consistent in detecting changes in their condition. Herscu et al. found that mindfulness meditation combined with self-monitoring reduced maladaptive daydreaming symptoms, demonstrating that mindful awareness can work synergistically with structured observation of internal states (3). Zainal and Newman also examined mindfulness ecological momentary intervention and self-monitoring approaches, highlighting the therapeutic importance of real-time awareness and observation processes (4). Although these studies were conducted in different clinical contexts, they support the broader mechanism by which mindfulness can strengthen attention to relevant internal and behavioral cues.

Mindfulness-based interventions have also shown promise specifically in cardiac populations. Cavalcante et al., in a systematic review of mindfulness meditation programs among patients with heart failure, concluded that these interventions have the potential to improve quality of life and psychological functioning (16). Kazemeini et al. also reported that mindfulness-based cognitive therapy was effective in modifying cognitive emotion regulation in patients with heart failure (17). Better emotion regulation may facilitate self-monitoring because patients who can tolerate distressing physical information are less likely to avoid attending to symptoms. In practical terms, mindfulness may help patients notice a change in breathlessness or fatigue without immediately becoming overwhelmed by fear or, conversely, dismissing the symptom to avoid anxiety.

Compassion-focused therapy also improved self-monitoring behavior, and its effect was stronger than that of mindfulness-based cognitive therapy. This difference may be explained by the emotional meaning of self-monitoring in chronic heart failure. Monitoring physical symptoms can sometimes evoke fear, shame, guilt, or frustration, particularly when patients perceive worsening symptoms as evidence that they are failing to manage their illness successfully. Compassion-focused therapy may reduce this defensive response by encouraging patients to approach signs of difficulty with concern and care rather than blame. When a patient interprets symptom monitoring as an act of self-protection instead of a reminder of vulnerability or failure, adherence to monitoring behaviors may increase. The therapy may therefore affect not only awareness but also the motivational and emotional context in which self-observation occurs.

This interpretation is supported by earlier work directly comparing compassion-based therapy and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy in people with heart failure. Ochghaz et al. reported that both interventions reduced fear of compassion and self-criticism in this population (18). Reduced self-criticism may be particularly important for explaining the stronger effect of compassion-focused therapy observed in the present study. If patients are less likely to criticize themselves when they detect poor adherence, symptom worsening, or difficulty following medical recommendations, they may remain more engaged in monitoring rather than withdrawing from the task. Thus, compassion-focused therapy may enhance self-monitoring by changing the emotional consequences of paying attention to one's illness.

The superiority of compassion-focused therapy over mindfulness-based cognitive therapy in self-efficacy may be interpreted similarly. Both treatments can improve awareness and regulation, but compassion-focused therapy explicitly targets the manner in which individuals respond to their own limitations and perceived failures. This distinction may be especially relevant in chronic heart failure, where functional limitations can challenge personal identity and perceived autonomy. By cultivating a compassionate inner dialogue and normalizing vulnerability, compassion-focused therapy may more directly strengthen patients' sense that they remain capable of meaningful action even when symptoms persist. This mechanism is consistent with findings linking self-compassion to self-efficacy and quality of life in chronic illness (8) and with research showing that compassion-based therapy can improve self-efficacy in other psychologically demanding populations (7).

The maintenance of treatment gains at the three-month follow-up is another important finding. Both intervention groups retained higher levels of self-efficacy and self-monitoring than the control group, suggesting that the effects were not limited to the immediate treatment period. The persistence of gains may reflect the acquisition of skills that can be repeatedly applied outside therapy sessions. Compassion-focused participants learned practices such as soothing-rhythm breathing, compassionate imagery, and compassionate responses to self-criticism, while mindfulness-based cognitive therapy participants practiced mindful breathing, body awareness, and cognitive decentering. Both sets of skills can be independently applied in everyday situations, which may support continued improvement after formal treatment ends. The continued advantage of compassion-focused therapy at follow-up further suggests that compassionate self-regulation may have become integrated into participants' ongoing management of illness-related challenges.

The overall findings are also consistent with the broader literature indicating that psychological interventions can modify self-efficacy across different chronic or persistent conditions. Positive psychology-based training has been shown to improve self-efficacy and mindfulness (1), while mindfulness-related approaches have been associated with improved self-efficacy in chronic pain populations (2, 12). Similarly, compassion-based interventions have demonstrated beneficial effects on self-efficacy and other self-regulatory outcomes (7, 9). The convergence of these findings suggests that perceived capability is responsive to interventions that alter emotional regulation, cognitive appraisal, and self-related processing. The present study contributes to this literature by showing that these mechanisms are also relevant to patients with chronic heart failure and that compassion-focused therapy may offer a somewhat stronger pathway for improving both confidence and disease-monitoring behavior.

Several limitations should be considered when interpreting the findings of this study. First, the sample consisted of only 45 patients recruited from cardiology centers in Tehran, which limits the generalizability of the results to patients from other geographical regions, healthcare systems, cultural backgrounds, and socioeconomic groups. Second, the study included patients with relatively stable chronic heart failure and did not include individuals with more severe or acutely decompensated disease, so the findings may not apply to patients with advanced clinical instability. Third, the outcome variables were primarily assessed using self-report measures, which may be influenced by social desirability, recall bias, or participants' interpretations of questionnaire items. Fourth, although the three-month follow-up provided evidence regarding short-term maintenance, it was not sufficient to determine whether treatment gains persist over longer periods. Fifth, therapist effects and treatment expectancy may have influenced outcomes, and the study did not include an active psychological control condition. Finally, behavioral indicators such as medication adherence, daily weight monitoring, hospital readmission, or objective physiological data were not included, which restricts conclusions regarding the extent to which changes in psychological and self-reported behavioral variables translated into measurable clinical outcomes.

Future studies should replicate these findings with larger and more diverse samples drawn from multiple hospitals and different regions in order to improve external validity. Longer follow-up periods of six months, one year, or more would help determine the stability of treatment effects and whether booster sessions are needed to maintain gains. Future research should also include objective behavioral and clinical indicators, such as adherence to daily weight monitoring, medication adherence, physical activity, emergency visits, hospitalization rates, and relevant cardiac biomarkers. It would also be useful to examine potential mediators of treatment response, including self-criticism, psychological flexibility, emotional regulation, perceived social support, health anxiety, and illness perception. Comparative studies could evaluate whether certain patient characteristics predict better response to compassion-focused therapy or mindfulness-based cognitive therapy. In addition, dismantling studies could identify which specific components of each intervention are most strongly associated with changes in self-efficacy and self-monitoring. Future research may also examine combined or sequential interventions integrating compassion and mindfulness to determine whether complementary mechanisms produce stronger or more durable effects than either intervention alone.

The findings suggest that psychological interventions should be considered as complementary components of multidisciplinary care for patients with chronic heart failure. Cardiology clinics may benefit from incorporating structured compassion-focused or mindfulness-based programs alongside routine medical treatment, particularly for patients who show low confidence in disease management or inconsistent symptom monitoring. Compassion-focused therapy may be especially appropriate for patients who exhibit pronounced self-criticism, shame, helplessness, or discouragement related to their illness, whereas mindfulness-based cognitive therapy may be particularly useful for patients who struggle with catastrophic interpretations of bodily sensations, attentional dysregulation, or automatic emotional reactions. Nurses, psychologists, and rehabilitation professionals can also reinforce simple practices derived from these interventions, such as compassionate self-talk, nonjudgmental symptom observation, brief breathing exercises, and structured monitoring routines. Integrating these techniques into cardiac rehabilitation and patient education programs may help patients become more active and confident participants in long-term disease management.

Acknowledgments

The authors express their deep gratitude to all participants who contributed to this study.

Authors’ Contributions

All authors equally contributed to this study.

Declaration of Interest

The authors of this article declared no conflict of interest.

Ethical Considerations

The study protocol adhered to the principles outlined in the Helsinki Declaration, which provides guidelines for ethical research involving human participants.

Transparency of Data

In accordance with the principles of transparency and open research, we declare that all data and materials used in this study are available upon request.

Funding

This research was carried out independently with personal funding and without the financial support of any governmental or private institution or organization.

References

  • 1. Allahdini Hesaroueiyeh M, Sanagou Moharer G, Shirazi M. The efficacy of skills training based on positive psychology on self-efficacy and mindfulness in sports of chronic mental patients. Journal-of-Psychological-Science. 2022;21(110):401-18. doi: 10.52547/JPS.21.110.401.
  • 2. Rizzo JM, Schwartz RC. The effect of mindfulness, psychological flexibility, and emotional intelligence on self-efficacy and functional outcomes among chronic pain clients. Journal of Contemporary Psychotherapy: On the Cutting Edge of Modern Developments in Psychotherapy. 2021;51(2):109-16. doi: 10.1007/s10879-020-09481-5.
  • 3. Herscu O, Somer E, Federman A, Soffer-Dudek N. Mindfulness meditation and self-monitoring reduced maladaptive daydreaming symptoms: A randomized controlled trial of a brief self-guided web-based program. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 2023. doi: 10.1037/ccp0000790.
  • 4. Zainal NH, Newman MG. Which Client with Generalized Anxiety Disorder Benefits from a Mindfulness Ecological Momentary Intervention versus a Self-Monitoring App? Developing a Multivariable Machine-Learning Predictive Model. Journal of Anxiety Disorders. 2024;102:102825. doi: 10.1016/j.janxdis.2024.102825.
  • 5. Al-Hammouri MM, Rababah JA, Aldalaykeh M. Exploring the potential of acceptance and commitment therapy model in self-care behaviour in persons with heart failure. Nursing Open. 2020;7(5):1560-7. doi: 10.1002/nop2.538.
  • 6. Boonlue C, Srisawet S. Self-compassion in parents of children with chronic illnesses: A concept analysis. Belitung Nursing Journal. 2025;11(3):278-87. doi: 10.33546/bnj.3833.
  • 7. Dabbagh A, Haroun Rashidi H. The Effectiveness of Compassion-Based Therapy on Self-Efficacy, Emotion Regulation, and Quality of Life in Mothers of Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder. Eighth National Conference on Professional Research in Psychology and Counseling with a Teacher-Perspective Approach; Bandar Abbas2026.
  • 8. Ebadi M, Azmoudeh M, Eghbali A, Chalabianloo G. Structural Equations of the Relationship between Self-Compassion and Quality of Life and the Mediating Role of Self-Efficacy in Individuals with Type 2 Diabetes: A Descriptive Study. Journal of Rafsanjan University of Medical Sciences. 2025;24(6):555-70.
  • 9. Mardani P, Tabaghdehi AF. The Effectiveness of Compassion-Focused Therapy on Negative Meta-Emotions and Sexual Self-Efficacy in Women Affected by Extramarital Relationships. PWJ. 2025;6(3). doi: 10.61838/kman.pwj.6.3.3.
  • 10. Seif M, Golpour R, Abdollahzadeh H. Comparing the Effectiveness of Compassion Therapy and Acceptance and Commitment Therapy on the Body Image in Patients with Chronic Musculoskeletal Pain. International Journal of Musculoskeletal Pain Prevention. 2024;9(2):1043-50.
  • 11. Zeinal Langroudi Z. Effectiveness of Self-Compassion-Based Training on Reducing Suicidal Thoughts and Death Anxiety in Chronic Pulmonary Patients. Mental Health and Lifestyle Journal. 2024;2(4):1-7. doi: 10.61838/mhlj.2.4.1.
  • 12. Turner JAAUAML, Balderson BH, Cook AJ, Sherman KJ, Cherkin DC. Mindfulness-based stress reduction and cognitive-behavioral therapy for chronic low back pain: similar effects on mindfulness, catastrophizing, self-efficacy, and acceptance in a randomized controlled trial. Pain. 2016;157(11):2434. doi: 10.1097/j.pain.0000000000000635.
  • 13. Miragha Pour Tarrah A, Asadian K, Esmkhani Akbari Nejad H. Comparison of the Effectiveness of Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy and Meaning Therapy on Pain Self-Efficacy and Quality of Life in Men with Chronic Headache. Anesthesia and Pain. 2024;15(1):1-12.
  • 14. Toprak B, Alkan D, Çelebi GC, Yıldız EC. Adding Mindfulness to Cognitive Behavior Therapy in Group Counseling: A Randomized Pilot Study on Self-Efficacy, Cognitive Flexibility, and Self-Compassion. Primenjena Psihologija. 2026;19(1):29-56. doi: 10.19090/pp.v19i1.2615.
  • 15. Parsons CE, Crane C, Parsons LJ, Fjorback LO, Kuyken W. Home practice in mindfulness-based cognitive therapy and mindfulness-based stress reduction: A systematic review and meta-analysis of participants' mindfulness practice and its association with outcomes. Behavioral Research Therapy. 2017;95(3):29-41. doi: 10.1053/j.ajkd.2024.01.007.
  • 16. Cavalcante VN, Cavalcanti ACD, Juliana de Melo Vellozo Pereira T, Figueiredo LdS, Mesquita ET. Effectiveness of Mindfulness Meditation Programs in the Promotion of Quality of Life in Patients With Heart Failure: A Systematic Review. International Journal of Cardiovascular Sciences. 2021. doi: 10.36660/ijcs.20200135.
  • 17. Kazemeini SE, Ranjbaripour T, NezhadMohammad Nameghi A, Sodagar S, Peyvandi P. Comparison the effectiveness of Acceptance and Commitment therapy with Mindfulness-Based Cognitive therapy on Cognitive Emotion Regulation in Heart Failure Patients. Journal of Assessment and Research in Applied Counseling. 2022;4(3):11-8. doi: 10.52547/jarac.4.3.30.
  • 18. Ochghaz MG, Mohammadkhani P, Hatami M, Mohammadrezaei R. Compare Compassion-Based Therapy and Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy to Reduce Fear of Compassion and Self-Criticism in People with Heart Failure. Contemporary Psychology. 2020;15(1):123-36.