Comparison of the Effectiveness of Short-Term Solution-Focused Therapy and Compassion-Focused Therapy on Self-Efficacy in Married Women
Keywords:
Self-efficacy, short-term solution-focused therapy, compassion-focused therapy, married women.Abstract
The present study was conducted to compare the effectiveness of short-term solution-focused therapy and compassion-focused therapy on self-efficacy in married women. The research method was experimental, using a pretest-posttest-follow-up design with a control group. The statistical population consisted of all married women who referred to the Hazrat Zainab Cultural Center in Mashhad during the 2022–2023 academic year. The sample included 60 women selected through convenience sampling and randomly assigned to three groups of 20 participants each. The instrument used in this study was the General Self-Efficacy Questionnaire by Sherer et al. (1982). The short-term solution-focused therapy was conducted in six 90-minute sessions using the Diamond model, while the compassion-focused therapy sessions followed Gilbert’s (2014) protocol and included twelve 90-minute sessions held weekly. The control group was placed on a waiting list. A pretest was administered before the intervention, a posttest after the sessions, and a follow-up assessment was conducted two months later. During the course of the intervention and assessments, two participants from both the control group and the solution-focused therapy group dropped out, along with four participants from the compassion-focused therapy group. The data were analyzed using SPSS-27 software and repeated measures analysis of variance (ANOVA). The findings revealed that in the posttest and follow-up phases, there were statistically significant differences between the experimental groups (compassion-focused therapy and solution-focused therapy) and the control group. The results indicated that both therapeutic approaches were effective in enhancing self-efficacy in married women and had lasting effects (p < .05); however, there was no significant difference in the effectiveness between the two approaches.
Downloads
References
1. Alizadeh Z, Dokaneifard F, Fattahi Andabil A. Predicting marital adjustment by self-compassion and marital self-regulation. Applied Family Therapy Journal. 2024;5(4):194-200. doi: 10.61838/kman.aftj.5.4.22.
2. Pedro L, Branquinho M, Canavarro MC, Fonseca A. Self-criticism, negative automatic thoughts, and postpartum depressive symptoms: The buffering effect of self-compassion. Journal of Reproductive and Infant Psychology. 2019;37(7):1-15. doi: 10.1080/02646838.2019.1597969.
3. Nasir-Herand M, Makvandi B, Pasha R, Bavi S. Comparing the effectiveness of schema therapy and compassion-focused therapy on self-efficacy and rumination in married female students of Islamic Azad University. Knowledge and Research in Applied Psychology. 2024;25(4):161-74.
4. Haji-Rostam A, Golparvar M, Khayatan F. Comparing the effectiveness of self-compassion-based mindfulness therapy and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy on weight self-efficacy and food craving in overweight women. Disability Studies. 2022;12(134).
5. Connie EE, Froerer AS. The Solution focused brief therapy diamond: A new approach to SFBT that will empower both practitioner and client to achieve the best outcomes: Hay House; 2023.
6. Jenkins C, Germaine C. Solution oriented learning: An innovative approach that promotes motivation and resilience. Mental Health Practice. 2023;26(2).
7. Naeimi-Pour F, Shahgholian M, Yariyari F. Designing and testing a structural model of self-silencing in married women based on attachment style, emotional expressiveness, loneliness, and self-compassion as a mediator. Journal of Psychological Science. 2024;23(143):23-40.
8. Erfa M, editor The effectiveness of compassion-based therapy in reducing loneliness among elderly women in the post-COVID era. 8th Scientific Research Conference on the Development and Promotion of Educational and Psychological Sciences; 2022; Tehran, Iran.
9. Sheikholeslami A, Ghamari-Givi H, Amini S, editors. The effectiveness of self-compassion training on self-criticism in women victims of domestic violence. 1st International Conference on Counseling; 2020; Ardabil, Iran.
10. Ghodsy P, Sajjadi S. Investigating the effectiveness of group training based on the solution-focused approach on self-efficacy and marital satisfaction in married women. Health Psychology and Social Behavior. 2023;1(3):17-32.
11. Farahani M, Hamidipour R, Heidari H. The effectiveness of indigenous solution-focused therapy on self-efficacy and emotional regulation in mothers of children with intellectual disabilities. Razi Journal of Medical Sciences. 2020;27(12):100-8.
12. Davarnia R, Zohrekar K, Asadpour A, Mohsenzadeh F, Kasaie Isfahani A. The effectiveness of group counseling with compassion-focused therapy on rumination in women affected by marital infidelity. Armaghane Danesh. 2019;24(5):950-67.
13. Asadi Bijaeyeh JS, Amiri Majd M, Ghamari M, Fathi Aghdam G. The effectiveness of the self-compassion training on life satisfaction and resilience of the elderly women. Aging Psychology. 2021;7(1):55-67. doi: 10.61838/kman.aftj.3.1.30.
14. Bagheri A, Goodarzi K, Rouzbehani M, Kakabraei K. Comparing the effectiveness of metacognitive therapy, solution-focused therapy, and endurance exercises on self-efficacy beliefs in female students with social anxiety disorder. Journal of Psychological Science. 2024;23(137):133-53.
15. Turns B, Jordan SM, Callahan K, Whiting J, Springer NP. Assessing the effectiveness of solution-focused brief therapy for couples raising a child with autism: A pilot clinical outcome study. Journal of Couple & Relationship Therapy. 2019;18(3):257-79. doi: 10.1080/15332691.2019.1571975.
16. Shariat-Zadeh-Jenidi G, Arvand J, Zandi A, Kivan S. The effectiveness of solution-focused couple therapy on marital satisfaction and adjustment. Journal of Assessment and Research in Counseling and Psychology. 2021;3(2):38-49. doi: 10.61838/kman.jarac.3.2.4.
17. Efafdoost-Sani Z, Zarbakhsh-Bahri M, Homayouni A. Comparing the effectiveness of self-compassion training and mindfulness in emotional control among neglected adolescents. Positive Psychology Research. 2024;10(3):115-38.
18. Ciydem E. The relationship between difficulties in emotion regulation and solution-focused thinking in nursing students. Nurse Education in Practice. 2024;79:104088. doi: 10.1016/j.nepr.2024.104088.
19. Kim DI, Lee HE, Park E. The effect of solution-focused group counseling: Effect size analysis by multilevel meta-analysis. Research in Counseling. 2017;18(1):157-79. doi: 10.15703/kjc.18.1.201702.157.
20. Taghavi SF, Gholamzadeh Jefreh M, Shahbazi M. Comparing the effectiveness of solution-focused therapy and acceptance and commitment therapy on the quality of life and self-efficacy of housewives. Analytical-Cognitive Psychology Quarterly. 2020;11(43):39-53.
21. Arianfar N, Hosseinian S. Comparing the effectiveness of solution-focused narrative couple therapy and short-term self-regulatory couple therapy on vitality and emotional control in distressed couples. Journal of Women and Family Studies. 2019;7(3):51-82.
22. Mir-Mahmoudi S. Determining the relationship between academic self-efficacy, psychological hardiness, and self-compassion with academic vitality in high school students. Recent Advances in Behavioral Sciences. 2025(58):112-23.
Downloads
Published
Submitted
Revised
Accepted
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Masoumeh Kheirkhah (Author); Mustafa Bolghan-Abadi; Sepideh Pourheydari (Author)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
